This article may include affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you shop through them.
Ever since I had an awful allergic reaction to the magic eraser – the little white sponge that’s supposed to erase anything off walls – I have started swapping out products that are more eco friendly, and less harsh.
The first few times I tried to use the sponge, my eyes started burning. I couldn’t initially figure out what was wrong, but soon realized it happened when I was using these to clean the kitchen. Worse yet, it started making my little one sick too – her eyes burned, her throat itched and her cough started, which was particularly worrisome since she has asthma.
The sponge – like so many other cleaning products – is considered an abrasive cleaner, so prolonged contact can cause skin irritation, dryness, or roughness. Symptoms like redness, itching, or a rash are signs of this irritation.
BUT salmonella is a thing, and it can hospitalize you or your kids and lead to some very bad outcomes – so you still need something powerful enough.
So I found alternatives, and I haven’t had an allergic reaction since.
These are 5 swaps from conventional, higher-allergen or harsher home cleaners to gentler, more eco-friendly options — including some DIY recipes you can make at home. These can help reduce chemical exposure (especially if you or your family members have sensitivities or have things like asthma or ezcema) and be kinder to the environment.
1. All-Purpose Spray
Swap out: a commercial all-purpose cleaner with synthetic fragrance, ammonia, or strong surfactants
Swap in: DIY vinegar + baking soda all-purpose spray
Recipe: Mix ½ cup white distilled vinegar + ¼ cup baking soda + ½ gallon hot water in a spray bottle. (Arkansas Extension Service)
Why it’s better: Vinegar is acidic and helps break down grease/grime; baking soda is mild and good for lifting debris. Both are common “green” cleaning ingredients. (David Suzuki Foundation)
Heads-up: Avoid using vinegar on natural stone or waxed wood as it can damage the finish. (David Suzuki Foundation)
2. Glass & Mirror Cleaner
Swap out: mainstream glass cleaner (often with ammonia and strong artificial fragrance)
Swap in: DIY glass cleaner with vinegar + water (and optionally a bit of cornstarch)
Recipe: For example: 3 Tbsp vinegar + 1 quart warm water; or ¼ cup vinegar + 1 Tbsp cornstarch + 1 quart water. (Arkansas Extension Service)
Why it’s better: Simpler, fewer chemicals and fragrance additives.
Bonus tip: Use microfiber cloths (which reduce micro-scratching) instead of paper towels.
3. Floor Cleaner (for sealed hard floors)
Swap out: a heavy-duty floor cleaning liquid with fragrance and harsh surfactants
Swap in: DIY mop solution with vinegar/olive oil/lemon juice
Recipe: For wood: 1 cup vinegar per pail of water; or for a polish: 2 Tbsp vegetable/olive oil + 2 Tbsp vinegar + ¼ cup lemon juice. (Arkansas Extension Service)
Why it’s better: Reduces use of synthetic fragrances and non-biodegradable surfactants; ingredients are gentler.
Note: Always ensure your floor’s seal is compatible — some wood/luxury vinyl surfaces may have special requirements.
4. Bathroom Disinfectant / Tub & Tile Cleaner
Swap out: bleach-based or strong commercial mold/mildew sprays with fragrances and strong chemicals
Swap in: DIY mildew/soap-scum cleaner with vinegar, borax and essential oils
Recipe: ½ cup vinegar + ½ cup borax in water (spray and allow to sit); or 3 cups hot water + ½ cup vinegar + ¼ cup castile soap + 1 tsp borax + 1 tsp tea tree oil. (Arkansas Extension Service)
Why it’s better: Avoids harsh bleach or high VOC cleaners; borax + vinegar still provide strong cleaning power.
Caution: If you use essential oils (especially with pets or small children) check safety and ventilation. Some oils can be sensitizing. (David Suzuki Foundation)
5. Laundry Detergent / Fabric Softener Alternatives
Swap out: conventional laundry detergents + fabric softeners with fragrance, optical brighteners, strong surfactants
Swap in: DIY laundry softener or detergent using vinegar + essential oil (or a mild castile soap base)
Recipe: Fabric softener: 2 cups distilled white vinegar + 20-30 drops essential oil. (Martha Stewart)
For detergent: one recipe uses 8 cups boiling water + 2 cups borax + 2 cups baking soda + diluted hydrogen peroxide + essential oils. (Martha Stewart)
Why it’s better: Removes many synthetic fragrance/surfactant components that can irritate skin or lungs; simpler formulations.
Note: Vinegar may not be ideal for all fabrics (or if your washer instructions say no vinegar). Always test.
Why these swaps matter
As we have written about before, In the U.S., companies can label ingredients simply as “fragrance” without listing what’s inside — so you have no idea what’s inside. In fact, a single scent can contain up to 100+ individual chemicals.
Because they’re considered “trade secrets,” consumers have no easy way to know which substances they’re breathing in or applying on surfaces.
Many typical cleaning products emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and may cause skin/respiratory irritation or other issues.
Using fewer specialized bottles and simpler ingredients can reduce packaging waste and chemical load.